Does Training in a Simulation Translate to Real-World Skills?

Safer, more efficient and cost effective – simulation training has broad benefits for workers and employers who need skilled people on the job quickly. See how it can help your construction business meet labor demands now.

CM Labs' simulated Compact Track loader with a bucket

The integration of personal computers into the normalcy of daily work and life is so ubiquitously intertwined, we hardly notice or pay much attention to it. It is everywhere. Smart technology is in every corner of our homes, our cars and even our job sites. While this can be a shock and a challenge at times, as some struggle to adapt to these digital changes, ultimately the benefits outweigh the growing pains. This is especially relevant now.

Worker shortages are something every industry is currently facing, and this is an even more critical problem where the know-how for the job traditionally required hundreds of hours of hands-on experience. In the past, perhaps, a new employee would start on a construction-style job as a general laborer, and slowly work their way up over a number of years, operating more complex machines and completing more precise tasks. It took a long time to develop experience.

Boom Truck Simulation exercise screen capture

That kind of process was gradual and allowed employers and production managers to test and select candidates at a relatively slow pace. It allowed job seekers time to size up the work expected of them in those roles and decide if continuing on that path was right for them. As an example, some crane operators had to log 400 hours of experience before being considered fully certified. This is no longer a viable option in the post-pandemic reality.

An increasingly large gap has emerged between the previous paradigm and the one faced today by companies eager and, in some places, desperate for people who can do the job both safely and skillfully. If you’re going to stay competitive, not only in the terms of labor but also in terms of overall business success, you must adopt a new approach. Thankfully, there are a host of new solutions for employers to radically and safely change the way new hires are trained, properly tested, and made real-world ready.

Why is this happening?

According to the Schwartz Center for Economic Policy Analysis, older adults (aged 55 and up) left the labor force and stopped looking for new work in record numbers since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic in March of 2020. The American Association of Retired Persons reports that more than 2 million workers were forced into early retirement due to either health or economic reasons, or in many cases, a combination of both.

A whole generation’s worth of technical skill and know-how has disappeared from the labor force much more rapidly than normal. Skilled laborers, heavy machine operators, and the varying array of support workers that make infrastructure jobs like asphalt paving and road building functional aren’t there to do the jobs anymore, and they aren’t there in as great a numbers to pass on the knowledge that they have.

Last year, an analysis by the Nation League of Cities (NLC) reported that three out of every 10 open infrastructure jobs (those related to design, construction, or maintenance) were more difficult to fill, compared to other industries. NLC determined while 19 days was estimated as the median time between job posting and hiring a candidate, in the case of infrastructure, it was taking 23 days 30% of the time.

“Labor shortages, misalignment between workforce systems and industry needs, a large wave of retirements, and lack of education about careers in the trades create significant employment challenges for the infrastructure industry. Moreover, many workers do not have access to the skills training and development programs necessary to build experience for higher-level positions, limiting career pathways to higher and more stable employment and pay.”

-NLC Press Release

Through the combination of these issues, a clear picture of the problems faced by businesses emerges. Large losses of established labor. A void in personnel qualified to train others on the job. Difficulties finding and placing new workers in available employment opportunities. CM Labs, a software and simulations development company, offers answers to employers’ challenges with customizable solutions for infrastructure-based companies, backed up with measurable results.

Enter the Simulation

Originally founded as Lateral Logic in 1994, then CM Labs in 2001, the company was focused on ground vehicle simulations. Christa Fairchild, product marketing manager for CM Labs insists that, despite the outer appearance of their machines looking very similar to an arcade video game, “it was a very academically founded company,” she said, “lots of patents and research, academic research that was invested in developing the secret sauce, shall we say, in our systems.”

The “secret sauce” she refers to is the company’s proprietary software and physics engine that makes the simulations possible. It’s the unique code that sets the “rules” for the simulation’s gravity, space, lighting, and more. They call the engine “Vortex” and it is the essential component to the success of their training modules. This, along with a collaboration with Trimble GPS Earthworks™ integration, means high fidelity, realistic earth-moving physics, and accurate spatial immersion.

Simulateur de formation Construction Camion-grue

Fairchild continued, “Objects are simulated in a realistic manner. When you sit in the simulators, they react in a way that would reflect what would happen in real life. That’s really important, because if you’re going to train on a piece of equipment that doesn’t reflect what happens in the real world, you’re setting yourself up for some surprises, both efficiency wise and safety wise.”

 

A Dangerous Game

Alan Limoges, product manager at CM Labs, added to this sentiment, explaining more about the benefits of creating custom training scenarios, “We look at vehicles that have a lot of accidents, right. What role can simulation play to help prevent these accidents? And where is there a need in training? These are heavy pieces of equipment that’s not the first piece of equipment a new, green operator would sit on. Simulation comes into play so they can get exposed to these machines early on. Then when they see them in real life, when they hop on the real machine, they have the confidence and it’s much safer.”

According to the Occupational Health & Safety Administration (OSHA), the construction industry suffers from one of the highest incident rates among high-risk industries. Statistics from the Department of Labor indicate that, in a single year, construction workers accounted for 1,008 or 21.1% of work-related fatalities. In a simulation, these incidents can be better trained for and avoided, as a new or novice operator can get hands-on experience in realistic environments and situations. Instructors can trigger weather conditions and randomized events to test how the trainee handles them.

Using simulators is also a huge cost savings, over the long term, when you consider all the metrics previously involved with traditional training methods. If you needed to train someone on a piece of heavy machinery, you had to have access, fuel, good weather, proper insurances, available instructor time, and more, to factor in. All that starts to add up with you are calculating a return on investment (ROI). None of those factors play as large a role with CM Labs simulations. With a simulator, you can provide training time to your candidate. It doesn’t matter what the weather is like, you don’t need to waste costly fuel, and you don’t have to stage a setting for them to practice in. It’s all self-contained.

So, the simulation addresses two of the current problems, but what about the staffing shortages? The best training in the world isn’t any good if there’s no one to train, right? Well, it turns out, the use of the CM Labs platforms has seen a benefit in this arena too.

Ready, Player One?

Even though CM Labs didn’t set out in the video game industry, the video game industry has now grown so ubiquitous that it is having a positive side-effect on the use of their training platforms. That is because of the overall familiarity that people, especially younger generations, have with the hardware and software when they either are exposed to it or engage with it. It shares certain commonalities, and it has an impact.

Alan Limoges again, “With regards to recruitment and targeting younger workers, those people are much more familiar with interfaces like screens and joysticks, which are part of the actual equipment that’s being used. They’re learning very quickly, but it is also attractive to them because the simulation and the simulators are awesome just to look at. They can create the tone of what you are going to expect working for the company, and can be a symbol for the recruitment process. They’re also very mobile, which means you can bring them to schools and job fairs and actually get people started on them right away. It’s a great way to connect with the next generation.”

Compact Track Loader Skills Challenge: Big Pile of Dirt

However, it isn’t exclusive to young people. A demographic report on video game usage by Newzoo, a market research group for game companies, found that time spent playing video games is higher across the board. Even the Baby Boomers are getting in some screen time. Here’s a breakdown by generational group that shows what percentage of those surveyed play any video games, and how many hours they play on average per week:

  • 42% of Baby Boomers / 2.5 hrs
  • 60% of Gen X / 4.5 hrs
  • 77% of Millennials / 7 hrs
  • 81% of Gen Z /  7.5 hrs

Even though these numbers aren’t directly tied to the way employment interests will play out, it is significant to see just how invested the contemporary workforce is in spending time each week in simulated environments. No matter what demographic is your target, the CM Labs simulators have high ceiling when it comes to their training potential.

The Hardware

We have discussed a lot of things so far, describing the market conditions, as well as the software that makes the CM Labs simulators tick behind the scenes. Now, let’s take a moment to look at CM Labs’ three off-the-shelf physical simulator platforms, how they are different, and which situations they are individually suited for.

Vortex Edge Plus

The Vortex Edge Plus simulator is a complete training solution that can run CM Labs’ full fleet of earthmoving, lifting and forestry equipment training packs. It’s an off-the-shelf platform, meaning you can buy and use it with a minimal amount of set-up. This version is literally a “desktop” piece of equipment, with a giant screen, laptop computer, table mountable joysticks and steering wheel, as well as a variety of foot pedals. It also comes with a carrying case for all the pieces, making it a truly ideal option when space is at a premium, or if the training location needs to be relocated frequently. This iteration is great for the beginner as it contains the same proprietary simulation software and realistic physics, but it does not include the chair motions or feedback that can tilt or shift weight, providing that great depth of immersion and realism. The Vortex Edge Plus is an entry-level solution, but still very versatile and helpful in gauging interest, teaching skills, and testing basic competencies.

Edge Max

Vortex Edge Max 

With a rugged, stripped-down design that minimizes simulator costs, the Vortex Edge Max includes the same heavy-duty controls an operator would use on the actual equipment, and the single, large forward screen rotates to provide an optimal field of view. This unit is its own space. Instead of needing the desk or table, the chair and the display are built as a single piece of equipment. The chair is a fully functional motion platform, its biggest upgrade over the Vortex Edge Plus, and is capable of meeting a large percentage of a contractor’s training needs. However, for the most immersive experience currently available, there is one final option.

Vortex Advantage

This version of the CM Labs hardware is fully immersive, and is designed to scale and grow with a company’s potential or changing needs. It has options for one, three, or five screens, and added motion platform to reproduce the feel of real machinery in motion, including vibration, impact, acceleration, and overload conditions. It also features equipment-specific swappable control sets and pedals, so that it can be retooled in as little as 30 seconds to a another simulation training pack. It’s an adaptable piece of hardware that can mimic your fleet.

In addition to these diverse off-the-shelf, ready-to-use products, CM Labs is capable of working directly with its clients to specifically design, fine-tune and customize the simulations used on any of the platforms to meet their needs. Limoges goes on to say, “we have Ph.D. qualified mechanical engineers that work at CM Labs that create the models, tune the hydraulic systems, and even the transmissions of all these vehicles. We work with our customer, until the specifications and the feel are exactly right. We do this to avoid any sort of ‘negative training’, where the real machine and the simulation don’t behave in the same way.”

In the face of staffing shortages and training gaps, one of the ways forward is certainly in the virtual world. Whatever your needs as a company or contractor, if it involves the operation of heavy machinery in specific environments, a simulation platform like the ones offered by CM Labs provides a lot of potential upsides.

[Find the article in Construction Pros’ Website here]